top of page

What Your Year Looks Like in Bullet Points

Writer: Liza Engel
Liza Engel
2 hours ago
5 min read

A performance review measures your value to an organization. It was never designed to measure your worth.

The template arrives—a few boxes, a word limit, a rating scale.


Into those boxes goes a year. Twelve months of decisions, setbacks and conversations in corridors. Perhaps a reorganization. Perhaps a hard stretch at home that nobody at work knew about. Somewhere between three hundred and sixty-five days and five hundred words, most of it has to go.


Engineers have a name for this: lossy compression. It is how a photo becomes small enough to send. The algorithm keeps what is easy to describe and quietly throws away the rest. The picture still looks complete. You only notice what is missing when you look closely. And here is the part engineers don't advertise: once a file is compressed, the original can never be fully restored.


A performance review is a lossy compression of a year. And like every compression algorithm, it decides in advance what counts as detail. What the review throws away is gone from the record. And if we compress ourselves this way year after year, it starts to disappear from our own sense of who we are, too.

What gets thrown away

For the past three weeks in the Soulful Reframe, we have been looking closely.


What you prevented. The most valuable thing you did this year may be something that didn't happen: the project you stopped, the conflict you defused, the mistake you saw coming. Reviews record events, and prevention is the absence of one. Done brilliantly, foresight looks on paper exactly like a quiet year.


What others value in you. We describe our own value in output: I delivered, I drove, I grew the account by 12%. Ask a colleague what they value about working with you, and the answer comes in a different language: you listen, you stay calm, you make it safe to say the hard thing. A review has no room for that language, so over time we stop counting it ourselves.


Who you became. Objectives are set at the start of the year by a version of you who didn't know what was coming. A review can ask whether you became who you predicted. It cannot ask who you became instead. With AI reshaping our roles faster than any planning cycle, that gap will only widen.


Three different losses. But they share a root, and it isn't the form.

What I saw from the other side of the table

As Chief People Officer, I read many self-assessments and sat in calibration meetings where leaders compare ratings across teams. More than once, I looked from the objectives on the page to the person in front of me and thought: these describe someone else.


The colleague who supported someone through the death of a person they loved. The one who spoke up for a colleague who wasn't in the room. The one who dropped their to-do list when someone said, "I really need help." None of it was in their objectives.


What stayed with me is this. A rating is partly a measure of your work, and partly a measure of whether someone in the room could put your work into words. The people whose contribution was hardest to name were the ones who most needed an advocate. Not because they had done less, but because what they had done didn't compress.

Value is not worth

Here is the root, and the distinction I wish someone had explained to me twenty years ago.


A review measures your value: what your work was worth to a particular organization, in a particular year, against particular goals. Value is real, and organizations are right to measure it. But value is always value to someone, for something, right now. Change the strategy, or let a technology rewrite half your role, and the same skills can be worth more or less overnight. You did not change. The context did.


Think of a house. Its price rises and falls with the market and with what the neighbors sell for. The house is the same. Its price is a fact about the market, not about the house.


Your worth is something else. It does not depend on this year's targets, and it is not up for calibration.

The trouble starts when we read one as the other. When "meets expectations" lands not as a statement about the fit between a year and someone's plan, but as a verdict on who we are. Most of us know the difference intellectually. Very few of us feel it when the rating arrives.


It is also why the self-assessment is such a strange ritual.

We call it an assessment, but most of us write a closing argument. An honest assessment would include doubt, failure and what we are still struggling to learn. An argument leaves all of that out. So the one moment in the year formally set aside for reflection is spent on advocacy instead. The reflection still needs a home. So give it one.
Photo by Bookblock on Unsplash
Photo by Bookblock on Unsplash

The second review

Before you write the review they ask for, write a second one. By hand, ideally. Nobody else reads it.

1.     What did I prevent? Picture the year that would have happened without you.

2.     What would the people I work with say they value in me? Better still, ask one of them.

3.     Who did I become this year that my objectives couldn't have predicted?

4.     Who is better off because of me, in ways nobody recorded?

5.     What did this year cost me, and was it worth the price?

6.     When did I feel most like myself?


Then write the official one, again. You will probably write it differently, and less defensively, because you will already know it is not the whole story. It was never supposed to be.

If you lead people

You hold the other end of the compression. Four small things change what survives it:

  1. Treat objectives as a hypothesis. Start the conversation by asking how the role has changed since they were set. Review the person in front of you, not the person in the plan.

  2. Ask the missing question. What did you do this year that won't show up in this form? Then listen properly.

  3. Credit the fire that didn't start. When someone prevents a problem, say so, specifically and in front of others.

  4. Count who carries the unrewarded work. Look at who organizes, onboards, mentors and smooths things over.


Research shows women are asked to take on these tasks more often, and say yes more often. If it is always the same people, that is a pattern in your team, not a personality trait. This work isn't a favor to the team. It is what holds the team together. Treat it that way: name it, share it, and count it.

Your year was never five hundred words long

The review will arrive, and you should fill it in well. It is a professional ritual, and your value to your organization deserves to be stated clearly.


Just remember what kind of document it is: a compressed file, optimized for one purpose, with most of the year deliberately left out. Your worth was never your output, and it was never going to fit in a few boxes.


Write the review they ask for. Then write the one that's yours. Theirs will rate your year. Only yours gets to decide what it means.


Comments


STAY IN THE KNOW

Thanks for submitting!

LIZA ENGEL

Worthwhile Thoughts

©2026  by Liza Engel

Site design by Alexandria Ervin

  • LinkedIn
bottom of page